Insurance Defense

Trial-Tested Defense for

Insurers and Reinsurers

We represent insurers, underwriters, and brokers in complex coverage and bad faith disputes nationwide, delivering strategic guidance on high-exposure claims while managing regulatory and reputational risk.

View all practice areas

National Reputation

Trusted defense counsel for major insurers and reinsurers.

High-Exposure Experience

Handling multimillion and nine-figure disputes.

Strategic Risk Analysis

Careful evaluation of coverage obligations and exposure.

Trial & Arbitration Strength

Proven results in court and alternative forums.

Why choose Barton Gilman for insurance defense?

Defending insurers in large-scale coverage and declaratory judgment actions.

Resolving complex multi-party and class action disputes.

Securing enforcement of contractual indemnification obligations.

Advising carriers on exposure and settlement strategy.

Representing clients in federal courts and arbitration nationwide.

Our insurance defense team delivers results in high-value coverage disputes

Managed Care Liability

Obtained federal summary judgment denying a $28 million claim for insufficient notice.

Workers’ Compensation Premium Litigation

Defended breach of contract and consumer protection counterclaims while recovering six-figure premiums.

Declaratory Judgment Actions

Successfully defended a major insurer in a $200 million coverage dispute.

Reinsurance Arbitration

Helped secure a $77.5 million settlement in a complex reinsurance matter.

Contractual Enforcement

Achieved fulfillment of significant indemnification and insurance obligations through litigation and negotiation.

How we work

Simplifying Your Journey

Claim & Exposure Assessment

Person typing on a laptop keyboard beside a second laptop displaying text, in a modern office setting.

We begin by evaluating the claim, policy framework, and procedural posture to understand defense obligations and potential exposure.

Review policies, pleadings, and claims materials

Identify coverage issues, liability factors, and risk considerations

Assess jurisdictional and procedural strategy

Strategic Defense Planning

Person in suit reviewing and holding a pen over business documents and forms.

Insurance defense matters require coordinated strategies aligned with policy obligations and business objectives.

Develop defense themes and litigation posture

Coordinate with claims professionals, insureds, and experts

Evaluate settlement opportunities and trial pathways

Execution & Advocacy

Person in a dark suit typing on a silver laptop keyboard at a wooden desk.

We advance our clients’ interests through disciplined preparation and assertive representation across forums.

Manage discovery, motion practice, and expert engagement

Represent clients in court, arbitration, and mediation proceedings

Handle multi-party disputes, declaratory actions, and complex litigation

Resolution & Ongoing Support

Judge in black robe sitting at bench listening as two men discuss a case in courtroom.

Our goal is to achieve efficient, defensible outcomes while supporting long-term claims and risk management strategies.

Negotiate settlements or defend cases through trial and appeal

Enforce indemnification and coverage obligations

Provide continued guidance on claims handling and future exposure

Let’s Talk —

We’re Ready to Help

Complete the form below and we’ll call you back to discuss your requirements.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.